OBAMA’S FAILED STIMULUS AND BUSH’S UNDERREPORTED RECOVERY

 

"The Obama stimulus ended the economy's plunge," says lying leftwing neo-Kaynesian economist Paul Krugman. "But it didn't work because it wasn't big enough (see)."

 "The stimulus was too small which was the fault of the GOP," said lying VP Joe Biden in 2010 when the promised robust recovery didn't materialize (see).

 

"The Obama Stimulus prevented a second recession that could have turned into a depression... but it wasn't big enough to spark a strong recovery (see)"

 

FRIDAY THE 13TH

It was Friday the 13th, the 44th day of 2009, when the Democrat controlled Senate, with help from three Republican moderates, handed the 44th president his first major legislative victory: the $825 billion mega-stimulus. Called the American Reinvestment and Recovery Act (ARRA) it was the stimulus of stimuluses, the biggest, boldest, grandest, countercyclical government spending program in history designed by its staggering size to reverse the worst recession since the Great Depression and prove at last the demand-side theories of John Maynard Keynes: that governments can spend their way out of economic distress and back to prosperity by stimulating consumption and demand through tax rebates to consumers; and create infrastructure jobs by giving money to state governments.

KEYNESIAN FAILURES FROM HOOVER TO THE JAPANESE

Till ARRA every Keynesian spending experiment had failed: liberal Republican Herbert Hoover spent a $700 million budget surplus that he inherited from Coolidge to end the Depression, massively raised taxes on the rich (from 24% to 54%) and went $2 billion into debt, but without success-the crisis worsened with every move Hoover made. His successor Franklin Roosevelt (Hoover on steroids) hiked taxes even more and outspent Hoover doubling his debt; but he too had no success-suffering a collapse of his New Deal programs in 1937 he prolonged the crisis he couldn't fix..until the war put America back to work by massively making arms and fighting totalitarian regimes.

OBAMA LEARNS FROM THE PAST?

The Spanish, Italians, Irish, Brits, Portuguese, Greeks and Japanese (for 23 years now) also tried Keynesian stimulus spending and failed. But for Barack Obama it would be different. Just as he was America's first Black president so he'd be the first head of state to make Keynes work. Why? Because he was smarter and wiser than his predecessors and learned from their mistakes-so he thought. What did he learn from Hoover, FDR, the Greeks, Japanese and the rest? Only that they spent too little, and unlike them he wouldn't UNDERSPEND. His Keynesian stimulus (unlike those before him) was "the right size, the right scope and had the right priorities;" urging Congress to act quickly in passing it he said, "the crisis [of job loss] was accelerating and getting worse.....and could turn into a catastrophe if we fail to act (see)." In other words, the greatest economic crisis since the Great Depression could become another depression if ARRA wasn't passed.

OBAMA'S FIRST BIG LIE

But this was a lie. The first of Obama's big whopping lies. For on the ill-omened day when this ignorant, arrogant, inexperienced man took office (bungling his oath as he would his presidency) the worst was over. The economy wasn't deteriorating (as it was for Reagan 28 years before) headed toward a new depression as Obama warned. In fact, the economy was in recovery and on the mend. Just as Bill Clinton inherited a recovering economy from George H. W. Bush so did Obama from Bush the younger (though not as strong). As you will see from the GDP chart below (provided by the Bureau of Economic Analysis, a branch of the Commerce Department), the contraction of the economy hit rock bottom and started a V-shaped recovery in the 4th Quarter of 2008 (late November/early December) when George Bush was still president.

http://academic.reed.edu/economics/parker/f10/201/cases/GDP_growth.jpg

You'll notice the V -shaped recovery begins Q4 2008 during in the  Bush era.
 
THE BUSH RECOVERY AND TARP BAILOUTS
 

   In short, far from the sky falling as Obama falsely warned the BUSH RECOVERY was underway when he took office. If deficit hawk John McCain had been president and resisted pressure from Pelosi, Reid and MSM for a huge spending stimulus bill the Great Recession technically would have ended all the same in June 2009 (still Bush's economy) when GDP was growing positively for the first time in 18 months.

Obama's claim, backed by Krugman, Reich, Zandi, MSM and the New York Times, that his colossal sized stimulus (that failed to trigger the promised robust Reagan-like high growth recovery) was a success in that it saved us from a 1930s depression is a provable lie.

In reality, it was Bush's TARP bailouts that prevented the economy from going into a depression by saving the US banking/financial system from collapse. Obama, Krugman and the NY Times have conveniently forgotten that-as they hope you have.

THE ROARING TWENTIES

The stimulus was a gigantic waste of money, and more than justified Tea Party outrage. The deep recession or depression that  Harding/Coolidge inherited from Woodrow Wilson in 1921 (with 11.9% unemployment) was turned into the Roaring, Soaring, Prosperous Twenties (with unemployment shrinking to 1.5%) by slashing taxes, spending and federal regulations-creating an environment friendly to business, investment and growth and inspiring consumers to spend.

OBAMA'S TRICKLE GROWTH RECOVERY

Obama (the great depressor of high economic growth) has gone in the opposite direction increasing taxes, spending and regulations and scaring consumers, lenders and businesses with his massive deficits and debt and divisive, anti-business, class warfare actions and rhetoric; and the consequence is terrible uncertainty and fear of the future (a public engulfed in gloom) causing the worst recovery since the Great Depression verging on a double dip recession-a weak, pathetic, trickle growth recovery of under 2% (for 2013) and now with a declining housing market again. The trend is clearly toward economic stagnation or recession.

THE OBAMA AGE OF AUSTERITY?

 

'Barrow and spend endlessly,' believes Obama, 'until there's a strong high growth recovery. If a $1 trillion stimulus fails then go for $2 trillion, then $3 trillion, then $4 trillion and more. Borrow Baby Barrow, Spend Baby Spend! Anything short of that is evil, ruinous, GOP/Tea Party austerity economics.'

While Obama falsely takes credit for saving America from an economic depression (though we're psychologically depressed) he now blames the failure of his stimulus to trigger a rip roaring Reagan-like high growth recovery on its size. What was the "right size and scope" in 2009 was in reality, like the FDR, Greek and Japanese failures, UNDERSIZED. But this too is a lie. For aside from the $825 billion fiscal stimulus the Bernanke-Yellin Fed (with Obama's blessing) has printed up trillions in fiat money in what has been the greatest monetary stimulus explosion in US history. Moreover, though Obama has spent $5 TRILLION over budget he laughably calls this UNDERSPENDING. And worse still the most reckless spending head of state in world history calls his last five years (and $7 trillion in new federal debt) the AGE OF AUSTERITY. It doesn't get any insaner than this. What sober person with a grain of economic sense would fault me as rude for calling Obama an economic lunatic repeating the Keynesian errors of the past on a colossal scale, while leading us down the path of national bankruptcy and blood in the streets?
 
RELATED
 
 

HOW THE AGES WILL RANK AND REMEMBER THE PRESIDENCY OF BARACK HUSSEIN OBAMA

14 thoughts on “OBAMA’S FAILED STIMULUS AND BUSH’S UNDERREPORTED RECOVERY

  1. Democrats owned the White House, the US Senate, and the US House of Representatives for two straight years and could have done ANYTHING they desired (as proven by the ObamaCare Train Wreck that is a 100% Democrat-Created Disaster).

  2. Democrats owned the White House, the US Senate, and the US House of Representatives for two straight years and could have done anything they desired (as proven by the ObamaCare Train Wreck that is a 100% Democrat-Created Disaster). That means Obama could have got a bigger stimulus if he wanted.

  3. Apparently, some conservatives like Apollo1) don’t understand what ‘stimulus’ means or how it works, and 2) can’t or won’t comprehend that it was the Republican plan for recovery. President Obama merely continued what President Bush started. But President Obama is a Democrat so it’s vitally important that he’s attacked even when continuing a GOP plan. These are the same people who complained when President Obama eliminated Osama Bin Laden after their own President gave up the search.

    1. Please provide us with a full audit of exactly where that $800+ billion went. Can’t wait for your reply, as we all want to know, as to date, the Obama Administration has not provided such an audit, nor have they told us where “our” money went.

    2. Screaming Frank…Had you paid attention, you would have seen that the money Bush gave to businesses has been paid back in FULL.
      Obama wasted the money on trivial things, and got nothing done. Part of the money was spent on a dog park for the elites in DC. That’s no stimulus!! It is pure paying back cronies, and getting blessings from Washington big wigs.

    3. Frank:

      When the Senate passed ARRA on February 13, 2009 it was one year to the very day that George Bush signed a stimulus spending bill into law-the purpose of which was to end the recession by giving consumers $150 billion in tax rebates. What didn’t work for Bush was not going to work for Obama though his rebate was three times larger. What the stimulus means is FAILURE.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *